Judging.

Score each film from 1 to 5 on four things. Story: hook, structure, a character worth the runtime. Craft: framing, light, sound, edit. Direction: the model was directed, not prompted and hoped for; consistent character and product, controlled shots. Originality: would you remember it tomorrow. Notes go to the team.

The scale: 1 missing, 2 rough, 3 works, 4 strong, 5 you would share it. Ties: higher Story wins, then higher Direction.